Stay at The Reform Club, a 4.6-rated boutique hotel in Amagansett offering plush suites, free gourmet breakfast, beach parking, and easy access to Indian Wells Beach.
Recent visitors highlight the blend of elegant design, attentive service, and peaceful surroundings, balanced by some practical connectivity concerns.
GoHotelly doesn't process bookings — we open this property on each partner so you can compare live rates, cancellation rules and loyalty perks side by side.
Some links are affiliate — if you book, GoHotelly may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Read the full disclosure.
Rooms, shared spaces, dining and exterior — grouped so you can skim quickly.
Situated at 23 Windmill Lane in Amagansett, The Reform Club offers a boutique hotel experience featuring plush suites and cottages set within beautifully maintained grounds, including an apple orchard. The property’s calm and spacious environment provides a mix of laid-back luxury paired with Hamptons charm, making it well-suited for visitors seeking a peaceful retreat close to Indian Wells Beach and the Guild Hall cultural complex.
Guests have access to several practical amenities such as free Wi-Fi, complimentary parking, air conditioning, and pet- and kid-friendly accommodations. While the hotel does not have a pool or airport shuttle service, it includes facilities like a business center and access to a nearby golf course. Reviewers often praise the comfortable rooms, attentive service, and delicious gourmet breakfast, though some have noted occasional Wi-Fi issues that may affect connectivity during longer stays.
The setting lends itself well to a variety of uses, from wellness and pilates retreats to special events like weddings, with multiple glowing testimonials highlighting the attentive staff and stunning grounds as key features. Its proximity to cultural and outdoor attractions such as LongHouse Reserve and East Hampton Main Beach offers convenient options for leisure activities nearby.
The Reform Club is recommended for travelers who appreciate boutique accommodations with a quiet, home-away-from-home feel and who value a location that balances access to natural beauty and cultural venues. While it may appeal most to those looking for a serene escape, its pet- and kid-friendly policies also broaden its suitability for families and group gatherings.
The short version: what's available day-to-day, and the key practical details most travelers search for.
Reviews from travelers who stayed here in the last 12 months, grouped to help you spot the pattern quickly.
The reform club is a beautiful and lovely property! The grounds are absolutely gorgeous and well kept. I stayed for a weekend on a Pilates Retreat and we took classes on the main lawn and in the sunken garden and it was just beautiful to move in such gorgeous spaces. The apple orchard is adorable and it was a pleasure to pick a few apples and take a walk through the trees. I stayed in the basement of a cottage and the shower was incredible!! The beds were very comfortable! Have to also mention the artwork was wonderful as well! Beautiful spaces, thoughtful design, pleasant service! 10/10 :)
I recently stayed at The Reform Club Inn in Amagansett, NY. The service was exceptional, with attentive and courteous staff making me feel welcome. The location is fantastic, nestled in the charming village of Amagansett, offering a peaceful retreat. However, the WiFi was a major letdown. For a place this expensive, I expected reliable internet, but it was extremely flaky, making it hard to stay connected. Overall, while the service and location are top-notch, the poor WiFi is a significant drawback. If they fix this issue, it would greatly improve the experience.
The Reform Club is the perfect mix of laid-back luxury and Hamptons charm. It’s got that exclusive vibe without being pretentious. The rooms are chic and comfortable, and the atmosphere is just right for kicking back after a day at the beach. The staff really knows how to pamper you without being overbearing.
The Reform Club was the perfect location for our pilates and wellness retreat this past weekend. The grounds were stunning and well-maintained, the accommodations were clean and thoughtfully designed, and the staff was so kind. It was an absolute delight. Eager to return!
The Reform Club is the city getaway I didn’t know I needed. The staff greeted me with warm welcomes & attended to my needs with great attention to detail. The rooms are cozy, vibrant and spacious giving that home away from home feel. I am looking forward to returning to the calm-chicc mini resort , especially experiencing the spa and the exquisite breakfast buffet once again!
I recently attended a wedding at Reform Club, and I must say, everything was perfect. The location itself was breathtaking, with well-maintained surroundings and beautiful landscaping. The staff were absolutely amazing, going above and beyond to ensure that every detail was taken care of and that all guests felt welcome and comfortable. From the moment we arrived until the end of the event, their professionalism and attentiveness were commendable. I highly recommend Reform Club for any special occasion or event you may have. You won't be disappointed!
The Reform Club is the perfect place to celebrate a wedding! As a groomsman in a recent wedding at the Reform Club I can honestly say that it's the perfect place to celebrate a wedding. The grounds are absolutely stunning, with lush lawns, gardens, and a charming apple orchard. The staff is incredibly attentive and helpful, and they went above and beyond to make the day special for everyone involved. I was particularly impressed with the guest rooms at the Reform Club. They were spacious, well-appointed, and very comfortable. I had a great night's sleep, which is important after a long day of celebrating. I highly recommend the Reform Club to anyone looking for a beautiful and unique wedding venue in the Hamptons. It's the perfect place to create lasting memories with your loved ones. Lastly the grounds are perfect for taking photos. There are so many beautiful spots to choose from, so we were able to get a variety of great shots especially in front of the light house. Overall, I was very impressed with the Reform Club. I highly recommend the Reform Club to anyone looking for a beautiful and unique wedding venue in the Hamptons, where you and your guests can enjoy a relaxing and memorable stay.
I fell in love with The Reform Club! I desperately needed space from the big city, and this hotel provided all of the amenities I needed to decompress. The rooms were in tip-top shape and squeaky clean. The staff was extremely kind and accommodating. They answered my questions about other leisurely activities I could do in Amagansett with great suggestions! I appreciated the fact that I could get a really good nice sleep at the end of each day because of how calm and quiet the grounds were. I can't wait to go back to this hotel in the warmer months and do it all over again!
This chic boutique hotel set in cottages is a mile from Indian Wells Beach and 3 miles from Guild Hall cultural complex.
Curated spots travelers usually pair with a stay in New York. Distances are rough real-world times, not straight-line.
884 reviews 101 Ocean Ave, East Hampton, NY 11937, United States
156 reviews 158 Main St, East Hampton, NY 11937, United States
355 reviews 133 Hands Creek Rd, East Hampton, NY 11937, United States
Hand-picked alternatives with a comparable feel, size and price band.
Stay at Cedar Springs Sportsmans Lodge in Rural Retreat, VA. Enjoy a 4.6 rating from 84 reviews at this cozy lodge ideal for fishi...
Plano Inn & Suites offers affordable rooms with free WiFi, parking, and kitchen facilities near Highway 75, close to Dallas/Fort ...
Ocean Sky Hotel & Resort in Fort Lauderdale offers oceanview rooms, beach access, pool, tiki bar, free WiFi, and nearby attracti...
Stay at Spark by Hilton Evansville East IN with free WiFi, breakfast, parking, and a pool. Conveniently near Angel Mounds and Eva...
Relax at MERCED INN AND SUITES, featuring free WiFi, breakfast, parking, and an outdoor pool. Conveniently located near Merced at...
Enjoy free breakfast, WiFi, parking & an outdoor pool at Howard Johnson by Wyndham Columbus Fort Moore, just minutes from Columbu...
American Motel in Lenoir, NC offers free WiFi, breakfast, parking, and a seasonal pool. Close to Lenoir Golf Club and local attra...
Stay at adoba hotel Naubinway with free WiFi, parking, and golf course access. Near Lake Michigan and Top of the Lake Snowmobile ...
Stay at Gatlinburg River Inn featuring balconies, free WiFi, outdoor pool, and petfriendly rooms near Downtown Gatlinburg and Sk...
Experience a 4.6rated Medievalinspired inn with free WiFi, breakfast, and parking in New Plymouth, OH. Near Hocking Hills State...
Short, honest notes are more useful than long ones. A few sentences about what worked, what surprised you, and who the hotel is best for will go a long way.
